The Command Post
Iraq
June 12, 2003
The Opinion Journal Weighs In On Museum Looting

This today from the Wall Street Journal's Opinion Journal site, under the headline From Tragedy to Farce: Anti-American journalists and the museum looting that wasn't."Why" is exactly the question that needs to be asked. Not "Why did they do this?" but "Why is the press so gullible?" A few weeks ago the collective countenance of the fourth estate was, like Hamlet's Denmark, contracted in one brow of woe. Oh, those savage Americans: What they didn't bomb they stole, or allowed others to smash and steal.

But wait. That story plays brilliantly but, as the London Guardian reported June 10, "it's nonsense. It isn't true. It's made up. It's bollocks." It wasn't the crazed Iraqi populace that denuded the museums but careful Iraqi curators, who spirited the swag away into vaults and secret storerooms before the war even began. Yes, there have been a few important losses. But there weren't 270,000 items missing, or (the most frequently reported number) 170,000. One museum official put the number at 47 items, but that was later revised down to 33. Meanwhile, the museum that was supposed to have been destroyed is scheduled to reopen next week. Stay tuned for further reductions.

About face, folks: The tape with the self-righteous denunciations has been taken off the reel while the new tape, full of self-righteous media navel-gazing, is cued up.Read the rest ...

Posted By Alan at June 12, 2003 11:19 AM | TrackBack
Comments

33 eh?

Hopefully thats 33 statues of Madas Husain

Posted by: Big E at June 12, 2003 12:14 PM

At about the same time as Donny George was (as late as June) bemoaning the loss of 170000 pieces, another museum official - a working-stiff one, not a politico - showed a reporter around the museum. It was reported that every time the reporter pointed to an empty plinth or case, she would smile and say only "That is safe." Bt that, of course, was not a bad-news story and got buried until now...

Posted by: John Anderson at June 12, 2003 03:07 PM

Sorry Folks,

This story was like a fish or batch of relatives over for a visit. After a few days it really bagan to smell bad. Who, amoung the people with their eyes open, didn't see this coming?

I hate to say it, actually I don't come to think of it, but the America is the root of all evil crowd looks pretty foolish. Their story of how this was yet another American failure just didn't wash. These people need to look in the mirror and see themselves for what they really are. Think that will happen? I'm not holding my breath.

Posted by: Insta-Gator at June 12, 2003 07:56 PM

The sad thing is that the impression is going to be left in a lot of people's minds that the Museum was looted and that the Americans stood by doing nothing to prevent thousands of years of Iraqi history be destroyed.

Those of us who are "Iraqi News Junkies" have been following the Museum story. Unfortunately most people haven't. Further, there is not as much hoopla over the artifacts NOT being looted as the furor over those terrible Americans destroying civilization. Thus the negative will stick in people's minds not the Truth.

Posted by: Belle at June 12, 2003 09:49 PM

Belle,

I fear that you could be right, or if you prefer, correct.:-)

Posted by: Insta-Gator at June 13, 2003 01:53 AM

Insta-Gator - Forget the nic thingy. I'm over it. Belle, however, is another story. There's a slight hint in her first sentence - she used the word 'left'. Were you leapin' to conclusions, or simply givin' her the benefit of the doubt? I could put this a different way - You WERE givin' her the benefit of the doubt, RIGHT?

Posted by: Dave Dubé at June 13, 2003 01:09 PM

IMO the American and Western European Left has evolved very little since the 1930s. They still countenance totalitarianism, refuse to admit to atrocities such as mass murder by Stalin and Saddam, promulgate grotesque fictional propaganda (such as the loss of museum treasures due to the dumb U.S. military/administration). The danger to democratic freedoms as we know them is much greater than most of us realize. I have reluctantly come to understand we are historically poised on a razor's edge, and if we fall the wrong way there will be no recovery....it'll be Leftist Big Brother for a long, long time.

Posted by: Tom at June 13, 2003 02:00 PM

Here's a scary, but edifying, thought:

Alexander Hamilton, in the third federalist paper noted (and I'm paraphrasing) that those that were most vocal about individual rights were indeed actually only demagogues, and interested in only those rights insofar as it applied to their own power. He notes that those people have brought down many, many governments throughtout history.

Amazing that educated men 225 years ago could in a single paragraph predict so much of what is wrong with our nation today.

Posted by: johnnymozart at June 13, 2003 06:00 PM

The really sad thing here is that this was quietly reported 3 weeks before it appeared in many newspapers --- as if the media didn't want to admit their incredible mistake until far enough into the phase of post "major-operations-in-Iraq"

RG
Providence

Posted by: RG at July 10, 2003 12:40 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?