The Command Post
Iraq
May 21, 2003
A Summary Of Middle-East Editorial Opinion

The Daily Star of Lebanon has posted a summary of op-ed pieces from papers throughout the Middle-East. Written under the headline Terrorism is a ‘cancer’ spreading through Muslim world, it's a collection well worth reading. You can find it here, and here's a selection:

Arab News (Riyadh): The pro-government daily says the real victim behind the attacks in the region is Islam and the Arabs, not the Americans or other foreigners. “The biggest victim of all is Islam. The actions of the fanatics feed Islamophobia. They send the warped message that Islam is a religion drenched in blood. They must stop.

But it is not enough to say that this is the work of a minuscule minority, that the overwhelming majority of Muslims are sickened by these attacks. It is not enough to condemn. It is not even enough to hunt them down and punish them. The world has to see that the cancer threatening the Muslim world is being cut out ­ vigorously. Unless something is done, it will create a backlash of its own ­ against Muslims, against Islam.”

Al-Ahram (Cairo): Columnist Salama Ahmed Salama slams US Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld in the government-owned daily saying that he is as “brutal” and “unfair” as Saddam Hussein for the way Arab prisoners are treated in Guantanamo Bay.

“It has become difficult to differentiate between Rumsfeld and Saddam as well as between (British Premier Tony) Blair and (former Iraqi Deputy Premier) Tareq Aziz.”

“Those who speak today of the atrocities committed by Saddam Hussein’s regime and the absence of justice under the Baath authority will realize that what the Bush administration is committing through Rumsfeld is not less brutal nor less unfair than what Saddam Hussein did.” American practices are “stirring up feelings of injustice and rage, which encourages hatred of the United States.”

Posted By Alan at May 21, 2003 08:05 AM | TrackBack
Comments

The Arab News is spot on and they are going to have to do something about it.

Al-Ahram if you find a mass grave in Guantanamo Bay I'll stop thinking your a waste of life!!

Posted by: Big E at May 21, 2003 10:54 AM

The Arab News is spot on and they are going to have to do something about it.

Al-Ahram if you find a mass grave in Guantanamo Bay I'll stop thinking your a waste of life!!

Posted by: Big E at May 21, 2003 10:54 AM

Salama Ahmed Salama is a Christian and has been one of the more moderate voices in Egypt.

Posted by: marc at May 21, 2003 11:19 AM

He's not very smart, if for him “It has become difficult to differentiate between Rumsfeld and Saddam as well as between (British Premier Tony) Blair and (former Iraqi Deputy Premier) Tareq Aziz.”

If this is what passes for intellectual progress in the Arab world then we'll be flattening several more of their regimes before they get the point.

Posted by: RF at May 21, 2003 11:45 AM

Failing to recognize the differences in treatment between detainees at Guantanamo Bay and "detainees" of the Iraqi regime is deplorable and does nothing but support the government's assertions that certain persons are of unreasonable character.

The humanity of their treatment does not mitigate the fact that they are held without due process. There needs to be an accounting of the detainees, and hyperbolic comparisons with oppressive regimes does not bring that reckoning any closer.

Posted by: TBox at May 21, 2003 01:46 PM

'one of the more moderate voices in Egypt'

I'm afraid that is probably an accurate statement. With friends like these...

Posted by: Reid at May 21, 2003 02:08 PM

Does anyone else find it odd that it is all right for our soldieres to shoot illegal enemy combatants, but somehow illegitimate to detain them?

Posted by: Gabriel Hanna at May 22, 2003 06:43 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?