The Command Post
Iraq
April 20, 2003
Iraqi doctors say they took risks to care for Lynch

CNN is practically throwing a virtual tickertape parade for Iraqi doctors for attending to POW/hostage Jessica Lynch's injuries and keeping her fed, cared for, and informed.

You know, like the Geneva Convention demands. Odd how CNN isn't falling over itself to praise the Coalition for its beyond-the-call-of-duty treatment of Iraqi POWs.

Let's see what was done:

Doctors and nurses at Nasiriya's main hospital say they defied senior Iraqi military leaders and Baath Party officials to care for a wounded American soldier who was held prisoner there for more than a week.

Ahmed Muhsin, a resident doctor at the hospital, said he and other medical workers smuggled food and news of advancing coalition forces to Army Pfc. Jessica Lynch, who was under constant guard while being treated for two broken legs, a broken arm and a fractured back.

There was no immediate way to independently confirm the doctors' claims.

Saad Abd Alrazaq, a hospital administrator, said Lynch was in shock when she arrived at the hospital. He said that she was given plasma and two transfusions, and that he gave her clothes from his wife's closet because she was covered by little more than a sheet.

"She had no family in Iraq, and we felt we were her family," Alrazaq said. "We would visit her often, sometimes with my children."

Lynch and a number of other soldiers from the 507th Ordnance Maintenance Company, along with several from other units, were listed as missing in action after Iraqi forces ambushed their convoy March 23 near Nasiriya. The 19-year-old native of Palestine, West Virginia, a supply clerk with the 507th, was rescued April 1 in a commando raid on the hospital.

Lynch's rescuers also discovered the bodies of nine other missing soldiers.

Muhsin said Lynch's guards beat her and tried to stop doctors from checking on her more than twice a day, but that he and others on the staff would give her biscuits, oranges, milk and medicine from their own limited supplies.

"She suffered from [the soldiers]," he said. "Largely she suffered from them."

The hospital staff said they thought it was their duty as Muslims to give Lynch the best possible treatment. Islam, they said, teaches that prisoners of war should be treated well.

If I recall correctly, the Iraqi Information Minister (aka Baghdad Bob) shouted that all American POw's would be treated according to the Geneva Convention. According to the Iraqi delegate to the Arab League Summit that coincided with the conflict, the claim was made that the Iraqis would treat all prisoners by what they said a higher standards, which they claimed was the Islamic way of treating prisoners of war. (Never mind the fact that portions of the Koran hold infidel captives in conflict as holding zero status and their Islamic captors are free to kill, maim, rape, and mutilate them)

If it weren't for the doctors managing to circumvent the Ba'athist guards and attend to Jessica, she would have been afforded neither.

Compare that with how the Iraqi captives have been treated. First real meals the've gotten since Allah knows when. No fear of being shot by their officers or loyalty-checking fedayeen.

Just wait to see who Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch and the UN complain about.

Posted By Laurence (Amish Tech Support) at April 20, 2003 01:55 PM | TrackBack
Comments

There's a difference between the coalition doctors taking care of Iraqi POWs as is part of their normal duties and Iraqi doctors risking their own lives and those of their families to care for their patients. As much as I detest the spin placed on most stories by CNN I can't fault anyone for recognizing those who went above and beyond like that.

Posted by: cynic at April 20, 2003 03:01 PM

Until Jessica speaks out on that, there's very little chance to find out if it's indeed true.
But it's certainly possible that doctors, nurses etc treated her well - and then it was very risky.

Posted by: IM at April 20, 2003 07:05 PM

"Well" is a relative word with respect to treatment. Perhaps these medical workers do deserve all the praise handed to them, but it is likely that their standard of care is lower than what we would regard as good to begin with.

Anyway, who cares what CNN says about anything anymore?

Posted by: charles austin at April 20, 2003 08:10 PM

I think the difference is that coalition doctors were unlikely to be tortured and killed for providing proper medical care to POWs.

Posted by: Bryan at April 20, 2003 09:27 PM

"There was no immediate way to independently confirm the doctors' claims."

Menaing, it could just as easily be people spouting off about how nice they are when the new boss is in town. I think PFC Lynch would be the one to confirm the story.

Posted by: chap at April 21, 2003 12:16 PM

Several thoughts:

Under the Geneva Convention, Iraqi doctors almost certainly are supposed to treat PFC Lynch, at least w/r/t life-threatening injuries. (The same, of course, applies to Iraqi POWs captured by the coalition.)

Also under the Geneva Convention, the Iraqis were supposed to report the capture of PFC Lynch to the US.

That the Iraqi gov't did not report the capture, and that Iraqi doctors were apparently threatened for taking care of PFC Lynch, suggests once again the fundamental difference in nature of the Iraqi regime and the Coalition. As important, it is interesting the thunderous silence that regins among those who bleated the loudest about the Geneva Convention and how we are supposed to treat POWs---why did they not criticize the Iraqis for not reporting PFC Lynch, and why are they not now criticizing the Iraqi regime for its apparent threats against its own medical people for abiding by the Convention?

Posted by: Dean at April 22, 2003 07:38 PM

The same creators of the iraqiinformationminister.com have created ParodyTimes.com a satirical online newspaper features news and event from a world remarkably similar to our own.
Don't miss the articles and pitures of the iraqi minister of information, George W Bush, Tony Blair etc

http://www.parodytimes.com

Posted by: juan at May 6, 2003 11:29 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?