The Command Post
Iraq
March 28, 2003
Geoff Hoon provides some context

In tomorrow's Times of London British Defence Secretary Geoff Hoon argues that the press acoounts of the war thus far don't show the big picture:

It may not be the journalist's fault: it is a reporter's job simply to report what he or she finds. But without being framed in a broader understanding of strategy, instant pictures can mislead. So while viewers may be "seeing" more than ever before, they may actually be "learning" less, albeit in a more spectacular way.

Those who saw the hectic pictures of a night-time infantry assault on an Iraqi-held position during the battle for Umm Qasr a few nights ago, for instance, will not easily forget them. What they may not have understood, however, is that the picture hid a more complex story. With our air superiority, we could have blown that building and other targets to pieces, but that would have run counter to our strategy of leaving the infrastructure intact for the Iraqi people, with whom we have no argument, to use after the regime falls.

Posted By Martin Devon at March 28, 2003 01:00 AM | TrackBack
Comments

I haven't RTFA, but did he watch the whole battle? We did blow away all those buildings. I think there were four of them. Tank fire and air strikes did the work.

Posted by: Andrew Hagen at March 28, 2003 01:31 AM

right. thank you for writing exactly what i was going to say! the distinction between straight news reporting and speculation about context should be made as clear as possible, unfortunately speculation is not only easier but makes better headlines.

Posted by: angrYkook at March 28, 2003 02:15 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?