![]() |
|
2004 US Presidential Election: Dean
July 28, 2004Dean SpeechFrom the DNCC via email, Howard Dean’s convention remarks: I was hoping for a reception like this. I was just hoping that it would be on Thursday night, instead of on Tuesday night. July 27, 2004Dean Releases DelegatesDean also released his 201 delegates yesterday and urged them to vote for Kerry (via Washington Times / AP). I’ll be interested to see how many delegates refuse to let go … Dean: "We are going to do what the Christian conservatives did 20 years ago"The Guardian reports on Howard Dean’s reception yesterday in Boston (“greeted like a star by party delegates”). More important, Dean is calling for a ground-up resurgance in Dem politics: “We cannot, as Democrats, decide we are only going to work hard in the places we can win,” he said. “The only way we can win is to run.” July 03, 2004Dean Supporters Vow to Fight for VP SpotAP: Dean Supporters Vow to Fight for VP Spot Message from a group of Howard Dean supporters to John Kerry: Pick the one-time presidential candidate as your running mate or face a floor fight at the Democratic National Convention. March 02, 2004February 20, 2004Who's the Big Winner? IowaThe state of Iowa is by far the biggest winner so far. The caucuses were becoming more and more irrelevant in recent years, but now they appear to have set the tone for the whole race. From the DesMoines Register Howard Dean’s departure from the 2004 Democratic presidential campaign Wednesday leaves standing the two candidates who emerged the strongest from the Iowa caucuses. Read my commentary here. February 18, 2004Dean Statement from "Blog for America"The official word from Dr. Dean: A Beginning not an End Dean Out: The ReportsFox News: Dean Ends Campaign but Vows to Keep Fighting CNN: Dean suspends presidential campaign Washington Post: Dean Ends Campaign for Presidency (Former Vermont Governor to Continue Political Advocacy) NYTimes.com: Dean Says His Run for the White House Is Over MSNBC: Dean Talks to EdwardsMSNBC.com is reporting that, according to anonymous sources, Howard Dean has been in talks with John Edwards as late as yesterday. No official word on whether or not this could lead to an endorsement. The sources, who spoke on condition of anonymity, also said that Dean had a lengthy conversation on Tuesday night with John Edwards, the lone remaining credible challenger to front-runner John Kerry. Dean did not reach an agreement to endorse Edwards, who has been actively seeking Dean’s backing, they said. Dean Officially DoneHoward Dean no longer “actively seeking” the Democratic presidential candidacy. He says he will support whoever the Democratic nominee for president will be. C-SPAN continues live coverage online. More soon… February 15, 2004Dean on Fox: I won't quitChris Wallace questioned Howard Dean on Fox News Sunday. Among the tidbits: He blamed the Washington media for bad coverage because he didn’t “bow down and kiss their ring.” He vowed to fight on beyond Wisconsin, and said “no one has told me that” when asked about staffers who were going to leave the campaign Wednesday. “Washington is sclerotic right now, both parties are wallowing in their special interests … Washington needs a good kick in the butt, and that’s what we’re going to give them.” At one point, Wallace got into a bit of an exchange with Dean over who was to blame for the mistakes in Dean’s campaign. February 14, 2004Dean Campaign Shows Signs Of EndingBoston.com reports, that Dean’s campaign is showing signs that it is about to end.
According to Boston.com, a sense of pessimism has begun to permeate the campaign. Staffers are talking openly about vacation plans and the pros and cons of working on other campaigns. February 09, 2004Now Dean Won't Quit If He Loses WisconsinThe New York Times reports that Dean has reversed his position and now says he will stay in the race even if he doesn’t win Wisconsin on February 17, 2004. The entire race has come down to this: we must win Wisconsin. Asked today whether he would drop out if he lost next week, Dr. Dean said, “No.” Dean Campaigns in "Must-Win" WisconsinHoward Dean is beginning his campaign drive in Wisconsin, which he has said he must win (otherwise he says he will drop out). Democratic presidential contender Howard Dean kicked off a do-or-die campaign blitz across Wisconsin Monday, telling voters they have the power to “keep this debate alive” and nominate someone who can unseat President Bush. Kerry and Edwards Take to VirginiaWashington Post reports on how John Kerry and John Edwards are trying to woo voters in Virginia. Virginia Gov. Mark R. Warner endorsed Sen. John F. Kerry for president yesterday, as Kerry and Sen. John Edwards campaigned among constituencies that could prove crucial tomorrow in the state’s first Democratic presidential primary since 1988. Wesley Clark has also been making the rounds in Virginia, as has Al Sharpton. Howard Dean was not in Virginia at all, instead focusing on Wisconsin, his “must-win” primary. February 08, 2004Dean Loses AFSCME EndorsementCNN reports that Dean lost the backing of a major labor union Saturday when the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees withdrew its endorsement. AFSCME endorsed Dean in November, citing his record as Vermont governor, his position on the issues and the strength of his campaign. Union leader Gerald McEntee told Dean in a meeting Saturday in Burlington, Vermont, that his union was withdrawing its support. Cross-posted from California Yankee. February 06, 2004Dean's Real ProblemNobody likes him. In a poll of the Wisconsin electorate (a must win state) Dean’s favorability rating was only 18% while Kerry’s was 42%. Favorability is always a tricky poll, but a 24 point spread demands a negative interpretation. FYI: Bush’s rating is 54% in the same poll. (Source: Univ. of Wisconsin Poll — Download pdf here … see page 4 for favorability data) February 03, 2004Dean doesn't answer calls from latin american voterFrom the wireless election connection Rigo Lozano, 23, is changing his support from Dean to Kerry. Lozano says he is affiliated with the League of United Latin American Citizens. He says he has been trying to reach Dean for the last 60 days to give him the league’s endorsement —he even travelled to Columbia to reach Dean, but “again no avail.” AP: Dean Campaign Fires More Than a Dozen StaffersBloomberg News is reporting that AP indicates that the Dean campaign has laid off headquarters and field staffers. Also, reports indicate that Dean’s campaign war chest has withered to about $8.5 million Dean Labor Endorsements in QuestionAP is reporting through CNN that Howard Dean’s labor backers are concerned about his slipping in the polls. Dean is expected to meet with some of his labor backers this week. Dean, who doesn’t expect to win any of Tuesday’s contests, will explain his strategy for staying in the race during meetings later this week with his three labor backers: the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the Service Employees International Union and the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades. February 02, 2004Armed Liberal: Lessons from the Dean BubbleLots of people are talking about the collapse of the Dean campaign (and a collapse it certainly has been, and while the race to the nomination isn’t nearly done, there’s no other word for what happened to him), and I wanted to toss in my $0.02 by suggesting a few things to consider. First, people have talked about the ‘echo chamber’ effect of the online tools the campaign used; I think it’s not so much the fault of the tools as a misinterpretation of reality on the part of those who used them. Here’s the model: February 01, 2004Dean Spent $6.5M on Staff, ConsultantsThat’s a lot of maple syrup. Here’s the Yahoo! / AP story: Presidential hopeful Howard Dean lived up to his campaign slogan “people-powered Howard” last year, making campaign staff and consultants one of his biggest expenses as he spent all but about $8.5 million of the record $41 million he raised. January 29, 2004Dean campaign "jumped the shark"Political pundits on Fox Live this morning were sounding the death knell for the Dean campaign after replacing Joe Trippi last night. One reporter mentioned a comment on the Dean Weblog that the campaign had “jumped the shark.” Two internet references in one story. The pundit spin on the Dean campaign continues to drive reality, which dovetails nicely with this post by Jay Rosen of NYU. There is something almost nauseating about this cycle, when journalists can both predict the next turn in it and go on to excute that turn. January 27, 2004Dean Speech SimulblogAs it happens:
FOX cuts before the speech is complete … January 26, 2004Dean predicts comeback, takes swipe at mediaSo say CNN: Former Vermont Gov. Howard Dean said Monday that he is making a comeback in New Hampshire, and predicted he would close the gap with Sen. John Kerry of Massachusetts before the Democratic primary Tuesday. January 24, 2004Dean Alleges Dirty Attacks in Iowa (And Blames Iowa)And he’s blaming Iowa as much as his opposition. Here’s the take at ABC News, which reports: Howard Dean said Saturday he was surprised by the “under the table” campaigning he faced during the Iowa caucus and said the state needs to prevent such negative attacks if it wants to keep the nation’s leadoff presidential vote. January 23, 2004It's Never A Good Sign ...… when you’re pandered to by the Washington Post … especially when it sounds like this: Dear Dean Team: Tips on Defusing Your H-Bomb. Word to avoid: Warts. An ugly word. “I am not a perfect person, believe me. I have all kinds of warts.” Too much information! Witches have warts. Kissing frogs gets you warts. There’s genital warts — don’t want to go there. Presidents do not, should not, have warts. As your candidate the doctor knows, warts are viral and incurable. You just have to wait for them to go away. We don’t have time to wait for his warts to go away. He has to quit talking about them. And the issues are …. where? Headline Of The WeekFrom the Hartford Courant: ‘Going Postal’ Is Out; ‘Going Dean’ Is In! Courtesy ED. January 21, 2004Humor Post: "Hardcore Dean"I debated about putting this on Op-Ed, but I think it’s in the spirit of good fun. So if you haven’t had the email already, enjoy this mp3 of Hardcore Dean. Personally, I think it makes him sound cool. January 20, 2004Arguing with Iowa: Edwards a big winnerEveryone will post thoughts about Iowa. Here are mine: Howard Dean looked like a pro wrestler on WWE Raw during his acceptance speech. Doesn't sound like a president, and makes for lots of fresh video for Republicans. Here's the audio if you can stomach it, courtesy of Blogs for Bush. BTW, this schtick is the big thing on "Fox and Friends" this morning. Probably will play big on all the conservative talk radio today as well. I expect an SNL skit next week. John Kerry talks about some new band he's listening to: George Bush and the Special Interests. And I agree with Instapundit, what's up with universal healthcare in his victory speech? John Edwards had to be the biggest surprise of the evening. His biggest drawback is that he sounds like a cross between Jimmy Carter and Billy Graham. But he's got a couple of things going for him: he looks young (so did JFK), and he's preaching a "positive" message compared to The Howinator Dean and John "F'ing" Kerry. While there's no predicting his finish in New Hampshire, South Carolina is just around the corner, and he's an N.C. boy. This is a campaign to watch. I have to wonder what Gephardt was thinking by putting all his bets on Iowa, of all places. He'd gotten some good endorsements in S.C., for instance, so why Iowa? C-SPAN was another big winner. It was hilarious watching the Kucinish Kid and the "now the voting's over, let's break out the wine and cheese" lady. Also the ponytail guy with the cell phone trying to call in poll numbers. Now there are some strong visuals. And nothing beats seeing Morton Kondracke in a safety orange touk freezing his butt off for FOX news. What happens now that Lieberman and Clark are back in the mix? Good question. It will be interesting to watch from the sidelines. Dean Wins!!!This may come as a surprise, but Howard Dean has already won a primary - the non binding DC primary. The Washington City Paper has a detailed look at how city leaders buckled in the face of being denied delegates to the Democratic National Convention in Boston. The January 13 primary was supposed to be a binding election that highlighted the voting rights issues in DC. Instead it turned into the kind of joke that is all too common in DC politics. Remember, as Chris Rock said of DC, "You elected a crack-head?" It is worth noting that Al Sharpton finished a strong second. Once Again ... Dean Can Blame SaddamI wasn't dreaming: William Schneider is AGAIN on CNN TV, talking to Larry King, saying that the wind began going out of Dean's sails in Iowa a month ago with the capture of Saddam Hussein ... January 19, 2004A Good QuestionCNN talking head asks about Dean: "Can you take that internet support and turn it into grass roots support ... that's very much in question." Visit Blog For America and to get the take from the horse's mouth ... January 16, 2004Dean's Growing TroubleAccording to Zogby's three day NH tracking poll Dean has lost fully 10 percentage points in little more than a week (down from 39% to 29%). Clark on the other hand has gained 10 (from 14% to 24%). Clark is now on the cusp of a statistical tie with Dean and with the Iowa outcome in question, Dean has real trouble. His surge to "front-runner" status may have done him in, for now he is expected to win. All Kerry has to do in Iowa is make a good showing. Dean has to win. If Dean underperforms, he could very well lose, not only Iowa, but also New Hampshire. This would mean near death for the campaign. After all, the mantra of Dean's opposition is that "he can't win". Nothing like a couple of loses (regardless of the margin) to prove that point. Dean could easily have avoided this fate by "Forgeting Iowa" as I advised him to do in November. There is an on going discussion about the importance of the Iowa caucuses. They don't reflect how the nomination will turn out. It's not even a real vote, its an activist vote. But Dean, the "front-runner" has given it meaning by staying in the race. The only reason we care about the Iowa caucuses is because Dean is there and Dean's inability to recognize that could cost him the nomination. January 14, 2004A Precaucus Pilgrimage to Plains, Ga., for DeanAll things old are new again! Via ED / NYT: Former President Jimmy Carter plans to appear on Sunday with Howard Dean in his hometown, Plains, Ga., providing a precious photo opportunity for Dr. Dean on the eve of the Iowa caucuses, which propelled Mr. Carter's own presidential bid nearly 30 years ago. January 13, 2004Dean is Back on the OffensiveEmboldened b the recent accusation from Paul O'Neill, Dean is once again reminding the public ... especially Iowa that he was the first to stand up against George W. Bush. From CNN: "Remember who stood up to George Bush first," Dean said. January 10, 2004Dean assures Iowans of his faith in caucusesFrom ED / The Register: Democratic presidential front-runner Howard Dean declared his faith in the Iowa caucuses and used his endorsement Friday by Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin to stem the fallout from the ill-timed release of Dean's past criticism of the caucuses. It's Dean Against His PartyFrom ED / Dallas Morning News: President Bush and the Republicans aren't the only ones to blame for Iraq and tax cuts for the rich, according to Howard Dean. His fellow Democrats are complicit, says the front-runner for his party's presidential nomination, and he intends to put a stop to it. Dean gets boost at crucial timeHoward Dean reveled yesterday in the endorsement of a top Iowa Democrat, a needed boost for a presidential campaign that finds itself reacting to news and no longer setting the political agenda as the voting in Iowa and New Hampshire creeps closer. January 09, 2004How Important is Iowa Anyway?Entrenched in an intense Iowa Caucus battle with Dick Gephardt, it is now being reported that Howard Dean called the caucuses a "waste of time" in 2000. Will the bad press hurt him? On Gun Control, Dean Aims for the CenterFrom ED / the Washington Post: It was a brisk winter evening outside the Elks Lodge here on Dec. 2, 1998, but inside, Gregory Costa was on the hot seat. Angry members of Vermont's two largest gun rights groups had a pointed question for the National Rifle Association's state representative: Why did he go against the wishes of many of them and endorse Howard Dean for governor? Unlikely scenarios: How Dean could lose primariesConsider this: Howard Dean wins the Iowa caucuses - but by a bare margin. In a surprise twist, John Kerry comes in a strong second, trumping Richard Gephardt. Is Dean Dem's Albatross or Savior?Is Howard Dean the Democratic Party's albatross or its savior? That depends on who you ask. Having improbably emerged as the leading contender for the presidential nomination, Dean has been attacked by his fellow Dems for his lack of political experience, his policy positions and his electability. So harsh has the anti-Dean rhetoric been, the former Vermont governor recently quipped "I keep picking buck shot out of my rear end all the time." And that's from his own party. Tide of Second Thoughts Rises Among DemocratsCourtesy e-democracy, this from the NYT: Only a few weeks ago, Jenny Briggs, an Iowa State University graduate, was all set to enthusiastically support Howard Dean in the caucuses. But now, with the vote 11 days away, Ms. Briggs said she is having second thoughts as she watches Dr. Dean stumble through his difficult days of the presidential contest. January 08, 2004Dean Backtracking on TaxesThere are some rumors of a mutiny among Dean's economic advisors as to the former governor's declared intent to repeal all of the Bush tax-cuts. A Boston Globe story yesterday "quoted a Dean campaign official as saying that there was 'unanimous' agreement among Dean's economic team that Dean should support a middle-class tax cut to offset the pain of his call for repealing the Bush tax cuts." Under the guise of "tax reform" some think Dean is going to cut taxes for the middle class, which would contradict his own preaching since day one. The Dean people deny this but say that the "reform" plan is still under construction and will not be announced until after primary voting begins. Could Dean be setting himself up for a run to the center in the fall (or even earlier)? (Full Story from the Boston Globe) January 05, 2004Bill Bradley Joining Gore in Dean CampThat's the report from the NY Times. Check the Dean Blog RSS feed over in the right-hand column for the Dean spin. Thank CarvilleJohn Fund argues that changes in the primary system helped ensure a Dean nomination: A year ago Democratic leaders were convinced a key to winning the White House was to minimize internal bickering and settle early on a nominee. That candidate could then speak for a united party against President Bush. The party has gotten its wish--a jammed early primary schedule virtually guarantees the Democratic candidate will be known by early March--but party leaders now seem to be having buyer's remorse. The nominee will be either the mercurial and error-prone Howard Dean or someone who may have a hard time exciting fanatic Dean supporters.A good question. I think the Democrats would be better off with a Clark or a Gephardt, as they'd be more appealing to moderates, but Dean will at least energize the base. While I find it hard to see how Dean (or any other nominee, frankly) wins absent a huge setback for Bush, Carville's instinct strikes me as correct. The longer the primaries last, with Democrats bashing one another and providing fodder for Republican ads, the worse off the eventual nominee will be. Indeed, the brutal fight between Bush and McCain in 2000 compared to Gore's easy defeat over Bradley was almost certainly a factor in Bush's difficulty the first time around. Cross-post from OTB January 04, 2004Bush Bracing For Matchup With DeanVia ABC News 7, D.C.: President Bush (website - news - bio) 's re-election team is bracing for a general election campaign against Democrat Howard Dean. Dean Received Warnings About Nuclear PlantThis Knoxville News Sentinel / AP story suggests candidate Dean was soft on nuclear plant safety while Governor of Vermont. Read it here, and here's a taste: Presidential hopeful Howard Dean, who accuses President Bush of being weak on homeland security, was warned repeatedly as Vermont governor about security lapses at his state's nuclear power plant and was told that the state was ill-prepared for a disaster at its most attractive terrorist target.(Cross-posted on the GWOT page.) December 29, 2003Dean held closed energy task forcePublished on Monday, December 29, 2003, in The Washington Times: * * * By John Solomon Democratic presidential contender Howard Dean has demanded the release of the deliberations of Vice President Dick Cheney's energy task force. But as Vermont governor, Mr. Dean had an energy task force that met in secret and angered state lawmakers. Mr. Dean's group held one public hearing and volunteered the names of industry executives and liberal advocates it consulted in private — after the fact, but the Vermont governor refused to open the closed-door deliberations of the task force on restructuring the state's near-bankrupt electric utilities. In 1999, Mr. Dean offered the same argument that the Bush administration uses today for keeping deliberations of a policy task force secret. In an interview with the Associated Press, Mr. Dean defended his recent criticism of Mr. Cheney's task force and his demand that the administration release its private energy deliberations even though he refused to do that in Vermont. Mr. Dean said his group developed better policy, was bipartisan and sought advice not just from energy executives, but environmentalists and low-income advocates. He said his task force was more open because it held a public hearing and divulged afterward the names of people it consulted even though the content of discussions with them was kept secret. The Vermont task force "is not exactly the Cheney thing," Mr. Dean said. "We had a much more open process than Cheney's process. We named the people we sought advice from in our final report." Mr. Dean said he still thinks it was necessary to keep deliberations of the task force secret, especially because the group was reviewing proprietary financial data from Vermont utilities. "Some advice does have to be given in private, but I don't mind letting people know who gave that advice," he said. The Dean campaign said it was "laughable" to compare the two. "Governor Dean confronted and averted an energy crisis that would have had disastrous consequences for the citizens of Vermont by bringing together a bipartisan and ideologically diverse working group that solved the problem. Dick Cheney put together a group of his corporate cronies and partisan political contributors, and they gave themselves billions and disguised it as a national energy policy," spokesman Jay Carson said yesterday. In September, Mr. Dean argued that the task force and the Bush energy policy were unduly influenced by Bush family friend and then-Enron energy chief Kenneth Lay. "The administration should also level with the American people about just how much influence Ken Lay and his industry buddies had over the development of the president's energy policy by releasing notes on the deliberations of Vice President Cheney's energy task force," Mr. Dean said Sept. 15. In 1998, Mr. Dean's Vermont task force met in secret to write a plan for revamping state electricity markets that would slow rising consumer costs and relieve utilities of a money-losing deal with a Canadian company. The task force's work resulted in Vermont's having the first utility in the country to meet energy-efficiency standards. It also freed the state's utilities from their deal with a Canadian power company, Hydro Quebec, that had left them near bankruptcy but passed as much as 90 percent of those costs to consumers. Utility shareholders also suffered some losses. The parallels between the Cheney and Dean task forces are many. Both declined to open their deliberations, even under pressure from legislators. Both received input from the energy industry in private meetings and released the names of members of the task force publicly. Mr. Dean's group volunteered the names of those it consulted with in its final report. Although Mr. Cheney has refused to give a list to Congress formally to preserve executive privilege, his aides have divulged to reporters the names of many from whom the task force sought advice. President Bush's campaign and the Republican Party received millions in donations from energy interests in the election before its task force was created. Mr. Dean's Vermont re-election campaign received only small contributions from energy executives, but a political action committee created as he prepared to run for president collected $19,000, or nearly one-fifth of its first $110,000, from donors tied to Vermont's electric utilities. One co-chairman of Mr. Dean's task force, William Gilbert, was a Republican Vermont lawyer who had done work for state utilities. At the time, Mr. Gilbert also served on the board of Vermont Gas Systems, a subsidiary of the Canadian power giant Hydro Quebec. Many state legislators, including Mr. Dean's fellow Democrats, were angered that the task force met secretly. "It taints the whole report," Democratic state Rep. Al Stevens told AP in 1999. "I'd have more faith in that report if the discussions had been open." Elizabeth Bankowski, who served as the other co-chairman of the task force, told the legislature that the requirement the task force meet in secret "was decided in advance by the governor's office and the governor's lawyer." * * * December 16, 2003Howard Dean peddles hate for cashAt "Howard's Hatefest"... * * * Who Says Dean and His Ilk Have No Sense of Humor? DEBORAH ORIN at the New York Post reports on the "no-videos-allowed" Dean fundraiser in New York in HOWARD'S HATEFEST. [Emphasis added.] [T]here were no TV cameras last Monday night when pro-Dean comics took the stage on West 18th St. in Chelsea at a $250-a-head Dean fund-raiser (reduced from $500) and competed to see how often they could use the F-word in the same sentence. Comic Judy Gold dissed President Bush as "this piece of living, breathing s---" and Janeane Garofalo ridiculed the Medicare prescription-drug bill that Bush had just signed as the "you can go f--- yourself, Grandma" bill. Just a few days before, rival John Kerry had used the F-word to attack Bush in Rolling Stone magazine in an apparent bid to sound hip, but Dean's event was "enough to make John Kerry blush," as rival Dick Gephardt's spokesman Erik Smith tartly put it. And the Dean event got a lot worse. Comedian David Cross used the N-word for blacks in a disjointed "joke" apparently based on the premise that it's fine for a pro-Dean comic to use racial epithets as long as the goal is to claim Republicans are racists. Comic Kate Clinton evoked Michael Jackson (hit with new child-sex-abuse charges) and said: "Frankly, I'm far more frightened of Condoleezza Rice" - the Bush national security adviser who has nothing in common with Jackson except being black. Rice seems to drive liberal woman comics especially nuts. Sandra Bernhard insulted her in racial terms with a "Yes Massa" accent at another Dean fundraiser the same night. Perhaps the pro-Dean comics find it unbearable that the most powerful black woman in U.S. history, close friend to the president and his wife - and a brilliant classical pianist to boot - dares to be a Republican. Actually, there was something to offend everyone. Dean rival Joe Lieberman got ridiculed for being unable to campaign on Jewish holidays because he's Orthodox. Vice President Dick Cheney was accused of talking "like Mary Jo Buttafuoco." Cheney's wife Lynne was called "Lon Chaney" - the long-ago movie star who specialized in playing ghouls in horror films. And Cheney's daughter Mary, who is gay, was called "a big lezzie." Even the apolitical "jokes" were ugly - like a suggestion that it's bizarre to see an Asian baby with Asian parents because so many Asian babies are adopted by whites. Dean was present and later deplored the racist tenor of the jokes, but took the cash and let credit go. * * * Classy. December 15, 2003D.C. Democrat calls Howard Dean supporter "poor white trash""White people don't understand our issues." Is this racism? If yes, is racism in this instance morally or legally wrong? If yes to any of the above, isn't this the official pos |